Thanks to one of my readers asking how to handle students who respond with non-verbal sarcasm in the classroom.
Sarcasm is one of those deadly sins in the classroom. Only the right teacher with the right mix of students in exactly the right situation can get away with sarcasm. Usually it’s to be avoided at all cost. That said, many students use sarcasm daily, even hourly! (or in some student’s cases, always.)
The benefit of non-verbal reactions, provided they do not physically harm another person, is that the result is always emotional. That doesn’t sound like a great benefit, but at least you will not have to call the school nurse or fill out an incident report. There are two important things to know when dealing with a student who is using non-verbal sarcasm.
First, realize that there are two causes for the behavior you are seeing. 1: the student has it out for the teacher, is very smart, has found your buttons and enjoys pushing them as often as possible. and 2: the student is feeling huge emotions and doesn’t know how to handle them without acting out. Knowing which is causing the particular behavior in your class is not necessarily important to the solution to the problem, but it is good to be aware of both reasons.
Second, it is important to remember that your job as a teacher, for better or for worse (and regardless of what Washington DC says), is to teach these students how to succeed in the world. This goes way beyond reading, writing and arithmetic (or whatever subject you happen to be teaching).
When a student responds with non-verbal sarcasm, it is important first to not react emotionally. You are the adult. You need to respond with maturity even when your student is not. This goes for your attitude too. If you are thinking immature thoughts, you cannot expect your student to act any differently.
The easy answer to what to actually DO is to do nothing. Ignoring the behavior is the best choice when the student is trying to push your buttons. Unfortunately, many times the student is experiencing strong emotions (frustration, hurt, anger, irritability, sadness, you name it) and doesn’t know how to deal with them, and so as soon as the opportunity presents itself, out comes the sarcasm and irritating behaviors.
If these behaviors are a repetitive problem in your classroom, it might be a good idea to start activities that help to teach students how to manage their emotions. Journals where they have to explain how they feel about certain situations can help them verbalize emotions that feel too big to express, even if about hypothetical situations. Role playing, where students have to act out common situations in life that require self-control and subsequent discussions about possible reactions and proper reactions are also good activities.
What NOT to do: discipline! unless the student does a specific thing that is against school or classroom rules, you should not give a consequence for the behavior.
Last tip: after school is out, sit in that student’s seat. Think about school from that perspective for a while and reflect on the student’s behavior, other students’ responses and your response. Sometimes reflection will provide insight that surprises you!
